How to Choose Your First Anal Plug: A Beginner's Buying Guide
By Sex Toys, Sexy Lingerie, Swinger Clothing | Published: 2026-10-27
Category: Buying Guides
Starting anal play? This guide helps you pick your first anal plug by covering size, material, and features. Learn what to look for and what to avoid.
Quick answer
For your first anal plug, choose a small silicone plug with a flared base or suction cup for safety and comfort. The Rainbow Plug (small size) and BLACK SILICONE PLUG are two beginner-friendly options worth considering.
Why material matters for comfort and safety
Silicone is the top choice for beginners because it is body-safe, easy to clean, and non-porous. Unlike jelly or rubber toys, silicone does not harbor bacteria and won't degrade over time. Both the Rainbow Plug and the BLACK SILICONE PLUG are made from high-quality silicone, making them suitable for sensitive skin and easy maintenance.
Size selection: start small and go slow
A common mistake is choosing a plug that is too large. The Rainbow Plug comes in three sizes, and the small version has a total length of 4 inches and a widest diameter of 1.25 inches, which is ideal for beginners. The BLACK SILICONE PLUG also offers multiple size options, so you can start with the smallest and work your way up as you become more comfortable.
Base design: flared or suction cup for safety
A secure base prevents the plug from being fully inserted. The Rainbow Plug features a strong suction cup base that sticks to hard surfaces and is compatible with strap-on O-rings. The BLACK SILICONE PLUG has an easy-grip handle, which also provides a secure hold. Both designs ensure you can remove the plug safely after use.
Your decision rules for choosing a first anal plug
- Start with the smallest size: Select a plug with a width of 1.25 inches or less for your first time. The Rainbow Plug small size fits this recommendation. If you are unsure, size up only after several comfortable uses.
- Choose body-safe silicone: Look for products labeled as silicone, like both the Rainbow Plug and BLACK SILICONE PLUG. Avoid jelly or PVC materials that can contain phthalates. Silicone is non-porous and easy to clean with soap and water.
- Ensure a flared base or secure handle: The base must be wider than the insertable portion to prevent the plug from slipping inside. Both the suction cup base and the easy-grip handle meet this safety requirement. Test the base grip before use to confirm it feels secure.
Product facts at a glance
- Rainbow Plug: Ultra soft liquified-silicone anal plug available in three sizes, with a strong suction cup base compatible with most strap-on O-rings. The suction cup base adds versatility for hands-free play or strap-on use, and the three size options let you progress at your own pace.
Rainbow Plug - BLACK SILICONE PLUG: Crafted with high-quality silicone material, featuring a smooth design and easy-grip handle, suitable for both beginners and experienced users. The easy-grip handle provides extra security during removal, and the smooth silicone surface reduces friction for comfortable insertion.
BLACK SILICONE PLUG
Who should choose which plug?
Best for
- Beginners who want a versatile plug with size options and a suction cup base for hands-free play or strap-on use – choose the Rainbow Plug.
- First-time users looking for a simple, budget-friendly silicone plug with a secure handle and smooth design – choose the BLACK SILICONE PLUG.
Not for
- Experienced users who need a larger diameter or textured plug for advanced play – consider larger sizes or specialty plugs instead.
